Christmas Unwrapped: The Wonder and Hope in the Birth of a Child

In one of my all-time favorite episodes of Star Trek, the crew of the USS Enterprise stumbles upon an extraordinary encounter with Apollo, a god figure from ancient Greek mythology. This celestial being resides on a distant planet, where he has created a lavish, idyllic environment reflecting ancient Greece's splendor. Upon their arrival, Apollo makes an imposing entrance and immediately demands the worship and adoration of the crew, asserting that he is the god they should revere.

He believes that, much like humans from his own time on earth, the crew of the Enterprise requires a deity to idolize and follow—someone to invoke their sense of purpose and morality. However, the Enterprise crew, equipped with a profoundly advanced understanding of the universe that has evolved over 3,500 years, takes a stand against Apollo's expectations. They recognize the limitations of deification and the importance of individual beliefs, freedom, and the progress humanity has made in transcending such notions of ancient worship.

The crew articulates their reasoning through spirited debates, showcasing their own evolved perspectives on morality and faith. Their confidence in declining Apollo's demands highlights their growth as a species and a powerful commentary on the nature of belief and the challenges of reconciling ancient traditions with contemporary understanding. This episode leaves viewers contemplating the significance of worship, the essence of humanity, and the true meaning of divinity in a broader cosmic context.

This encounter invites us to explore the rich and often mysterious experiences of those who lived in Bethlehem over two thousand years ago. It encourages us to reflect on an intriguing question: Was this event truly a miracle, a remarkable act that transcends the natural world, or merely a comforting narrative, as Karl Marx suggested? This thought-provoking inquiry encourages us to consider the significance of faith and belief in shaping our human experience.

While we may not arrive at a definitive conclusion about these events, one thing is clear: the best science fiction not only entertains but also sheds light on our shared human realities. It stirs within us a sense of curiosity and reflection, motivating us to delve deeper into our existence. This exploration is a beautiful reminder that our understanding of the universe constantly evolves. As we continue to seek knowledge and venture into the unknown, the opportunities for discovery and exploration remain boundless! Embracing this journey opens us up to a world full of possibilities where we can learn, grow, and connect with one another.

Ultimately, it is not as essential to determine whether things are science fiction (myths) or based on truth, but rather to focus on how these stories shape our feelings and influence our actions. Whether factual or fictional, the narratives we encounter often hold deeper meanings that resonate with our experiences, guiding our beliefs and decisions. Through the emotional connections we forge with these tales, we find meaning, purpose, and direction.

The Two Stories of the Birth of One Child

The story of Jesus' birth, celebrated by millions each Christmas, is composed of two distinct narratives that differ significantly in focus and theological intent. Even the genealogies in Matthew and Luke, designed to trace Jesus' lineage, do not align—Matthew lists 42 generations from Abraham to Joseph, while Luke cites 54, and the names vary in the two lists. These variations suggest that the Gospel writers prioritized conveying theological truths over strict historical accuracy.

Matthew's Gospel presents a rich narrative emphasizing Jesus as the long-awaited Messiah and King. The account begins with the genealogy linking Jesus to Abraham and David, establishing his identity in Jewish prophecy. This lineage is not merely a list of names; it underscores Jesus as the fulfillment of centuries of expectation.

A pivotal moment occurs when an angel appears to Joseph, urging him to take Mary as his wife. This encounter highlights Joseph's critical role in the divine plan, showcasing his character and faith. Following this, the magi, or wise men, arrive from the East, bringing valuable gifts of gold, frankincense, and myrrh. These offerings are imbued with rich symbolism, pointing to Jesus' identity and significance.

However, the narrative is not entirely serene. The ominous presence of King Herod adds tension, ultimately prompting Joseph's flight to Egypt to protect the child from danger. Matthew's account is profoundly rooted in the Old Testament, drawing on prophecies illustrating how Jesus embodies God's promises to Israel. The story becomes a beautiful tapestry woven through history, culminating in the birth of hope and fulfillment.

In contrast, the Gospel of John takes a more theological approach, presenting Jesus' birth as a cosmic event. The Prologue opens by declaring Jesus' divine essence: "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God" (John 1:1). This depiction identifies Jesus as the eternal Logos, emphasizing his divine nature and universal purpose.

Rather than recount earthly scenes like the manger or shepherds, John highlights the metaphor of light entering darkness. He presents the incarnation as a profound revelation of God's love and presence among humanity. While Matthew emphasizes Jesus' fulfillment of Jewish prophecies and kingship, his humanity, while John focuses on his divine identity and transformative role in creation.

Together, these accounts provide complementary perspectives: Matthew roots Jesus' birth in Jewish history and prophetic hope, while John elevates it to a universal significance to all humans. This juxtaposition invites readers to engage with the birth of Jesus as both a deeply personal and remarkably transformative event in the cosmos.

The differing narratives of Jesus' birth align with the Bible's broader literary and theological framework, filled with allegorical stories, parables, and poetic writings that often convey deeper truths rather than strict historical facts. Throughout Scripture, we encounter a range of genres and styles, each designed to communicate significant spiritual lessons to their audiences. The creation stories in Genesis present profound insights into humanity's relationship with the divine. At the same time, the parables of Jesus illustrate moral and ethical teachings through relatable scenarios that teach us how to treat one another.

This rich tapestry of varied narratives underscores a common theme: the Bible often prioritizes the theological and moral messages behind the stories over precise historical accounts. As a result, the accounts of Jesus' birth in Matthew and John reflect this tradition and invite readers to engage with the profound truths about identity, purpose, and divine hope that resonate across the ages outside of their supposed historical accuracy.

The Wonder of Christmas

Ultimately, the wonder of Christmas transcends the enchanting myths and miraculous tales surrounding the birth of a child, illuminating the deeper truths that resonate with the human experience. The stories we tell during this season—a miraculous star guiding the wise, humble shepherds witnessing the divine and the joyful arrival of a newborn savior—are rich with symbolism and significance that speak to our hearts. While often embellished by culture and tradition, these narratives serve a greater purpose: they invite us to reflect on themes of hope, redemption, and the enduring power of love.

As theologian, John Shelby Spong eloquently observes, "No myth is literally true. It is the nature of myth to point to a truth that limited words cannot fully express." Here, Spong underscores the intrinsic value of myth; it acts as a bridge to deeper meanings that can transcend the confines of literal interpretation. For instance, the story of Jesus's birth offers not just a historical account but a profound commentary on the human condition: a reminder that light shines brightest in the darkest of times and that vulnerability can birth profound strength.

Each December, we are invited to embrace the essence of these myths—not necessarily as factual accounts but as narratives that inspire hope and foster connection among people. They encourage us to look beyond our differences and unite in a shared human experience. The spirit of Christmas prompts us to cultivate kindness, compassion, and generosity, which can often be overshadowed in our daily lives.

Thus, the wonder of Christmas becomes a timeless call to action. It challenges us to embody the ideals that the birth narratives espouse: to stand in solidarity with the marginalized, embrace the transformative power of love, and believe in the possibility of renewal and new beginnings. We are encouraged to be like the Inn Keeper, finding space in the warmth of the lower level of his home home where the animals were kept for this couple expecting a child. We are compelled to follow the journey of the Magi, not just bringing gifts but delivering a warning that allows Jesus's family to escape injustice and oppression. We learn from Joseph that when we love others, we learn to accept them for all they bring to the relationship even when that is an unexpected, instant family.

Engaging with these myths reminds us that while the stories may vary, the core truths they embody—hope, love, and the promise of a better tomorrow—are universal and enduring. They invite us to reflect on how we can carry that hope within us during the festive season and throughout our lives, encouraging us to become bearers of light in a world that often craves illumination.

When we become overly fixated on the truth and accuracy of these age-old myths, we risk losing a vital connection to their deeper, richer meanings for our present and future. The arrival of the Messiah, as foretold to the ancient Hebrew people, embodies a profound sense of hope and renewal. It calls us to embrace the story itself, the promise of transformation, and the possibility of a brighter tomorrow. This enduring message of hope resonates deeply, inviting us to reflect on the true significance of the season.

The true wonder lies in the profound journey of rediscovering that over two thousand years ago, people believed in the transformative vision accompanying this figure, this Jesus. This exploration invites us to recommit ourselves to the fundamental values that such prophecies embody, urging us to actively work toward the future they envision. The wonder of Jesus is encapsulated in his life—a life that serves as a powerful reminder of our shared humanity. We are inherently imperfect beings; the expectation is not to achieve flawlessness but to strive for betterment, even in adversity.

Central to this journey is the call to foster inclusivity and community among all people. Jesus' teachings emphasize the importance of embracing one another and rejecting the notion of exclusion and judgment. His message encourages us to see the worth and value in every individual, irrespective of their circumstances or past.

The Hope of Christmas

Moreover, Jesus's true miracle emanates from his humanness rather than any divine attribute alone. Through the authentic expressions of grief, anger, frustration, and even hopelessness captured in the Christian Bible, we come to understand the depth of his experience. These glimpses into his humanity resonate with our struggles, making his story relatable and profoundly impactful, even to those who disbelieve his divinity. In recognizing these emotions, we find solace in knowing that we are not alone in our challenges but are united in our shared journey of navigating the complexities of life.

Thus, Jesus's legacy invites us to admire his life and embrace our role in continuing his mission—working together to build a more compassionate, just, and inclusive world for everyone.

When we contemplate the figure of Jesus, whether we see him as the humble human who walked among us or as the divine Savior, it is crucial to focus not solely on his miracles but on the beauty of the ordinary moments he embraced. Thomas Merton poignantly reflects on this idea, stating, "Into this world, this demented inn, in which there is absolutely no room for him at all, Jesus comes uninvited." This imagery captures the essence of a world that often feels chaotic and unwelcoming, illustrating how Jesus enters into our struggles without fanfare or recognition.

His presence is paradoxical; though he is a figure of divinity, he is profoundly out of place in a society that often values power, success, and superiority. Yet, in his humanity, he finds his true home among those who feel marginalized and voiceless. Merton further emphasizes that Jesus identifies with "those others for whom there is no room." He stands alongside the outcasts—the ones disregarded by a world that equates worth with status.

He is with those who are rejected by those in power because they are deemed weak or unworthy. He walks beside the discredited, the disenfranchised, and the suffering. In a world that glorifies perfection and conformity, Jesus's heart lies with those who experience pain, denial, and even extermination. The Messiah brings solace and a sense of belonging to those who feel invisible or dehumanized.

In this light, we realize that the true essence of Jesus's message transcends miraculous events; it is found in his solidarity with those who endure life's harshest realities. He remains mysteriously present amidst despair and darkness, offering hope to those who have almost lost it. In these ordinary yet profound connections, we witness the transformative power of his love and compassion. Jesus, therefore, becomes not just a figure of religious significance but a beacon of hope for humanity, reminding us that our value is inherent and that no one is beyond the embrace of love.

Jewish, Muslim, and Christian people may never agree on whether Jesus was the promised Messiah, whether Mohammad was, or whether we still wait for that child to arrive. Yet, in this diverse landscape of belief, we find a common thread woven through our shared humanity: the potential for hope that can come unexpectedly. It is this hope that binds us, transcending theological debates and divisions.

Chapter Nine of the Book of Isaiah in the ancient Hebrew text reminds us of this enduring promise—a promise not confined to a historical figure or religious doctrine but one that resonates in the hearts of all who seek light amidst the darkness, the hard parts, of their lives. It speaks to the universal longing for deliverance and peace in a world often overshadowed by despair.

In powerful imagery, Isaiah illustrates the profound transformation that hope (light) brings: "The people who walked in darkness have seen a great light. For those who lived in a land of deep shadows—light! sunbursts of light!" These words evoke hope for all oppressed by suffering and tyranny, reminding us that the dawn can break, no matter how deep the night may seem. The promise of new beginnings is encapsulated in the birth of a child—"For a child has been born—for us!" This child, named Amazing Counselor, embodies the limitless potential for healing and wholeness in our fractured world.

As we navigate our differences, let us focus on this shared hope, recognizing that the presence of light can guide us toward compassion and understanding. Regardless of our beliefs about the past or expectations for the future, our collective courage to embrace hope for better days can inspire change and foster unity.

Ultimately, it is not about the labels we wear or the doctrines we hold but rather the capacity to dream of a brighter tomorrow. As we honor our diverse traditions, may we also unite in our faith in hope—perhaps the most powerful gift we can offer one another. Let us walk together into the light in this spirit, guided by a shared vision of wholeness and peace for all.

This year and every year, we all need the wonder and hope of Christmas.

kfr, adapted from a 2023 homily. All rights reserved.

Learn More!